IRDAI returns to its first duty
Executive Summary
In "IRDAI returns to its first duty", regulatory experts Sumit Agrawal (Managing Partner, Regstreet Law Advisors; former SEBI officer) and MS Sahoo (former Chairperson of IBBI; former Member of CCI and SEBI) assess the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India's (IRDAI) landmark September 2026 consultation paper, "Recalibrating Economics of Insurance Distribution".
The authors highlight that the statutory sequence of IRDAI's mandate—established in the long title of the IRDA Act, 1999 and reinforced by the Sabka Bima Sabki Raksha Act, 2025—places "protecting the interests of holders of insurance policies" first, before regulating and promoting orderly industry growth. Following the 2023 experiment where commission caps were dismantled in favor of insurer board discretion—which subsequently led to ballooning distribution expenses, surging grievances, and falling insurance penetration—IRDAI has acted with candid self-correction to re-establish statutory oversight over distributor remuneration.
The Core Problem: Surrenders Outpacing Maturity Benefits
The article reveals a startling distortion in India's life insurance economics: life insurers paid more money to policyholders who surrendered early than to those who stayed until policy maturity.
- Surrenders Exceed Maturities: Insurers paid ₹2.33 trillion in surrender payouts, compared with ₹2.23 trillion in maturity benefits. This indicates that millions of consumers walk away from policies they no longer find viable, forfeiting hard-earned savings to cut future losses.
- Low Long-Term Persistency: Only 48% of life insurance policies survived five years when sold through intermediaries. By contrast, 71% of policies bought online without an intermediary survived the same five-year threshold.
- Commissions Exploded While Growth Lagged: From FY23 to FY25, new business premiums sourced through life insurance corporate agents grew 28%, yet distributor remuneration expanded by 125%, absorbing 27% of first-year premiums.
- Broker Surge & Mandatory Product Distortion: Premiums routed through general insurance brokers grew 37%, while their commissions surged 173%. Commission on motor third-party cover—a legally mandatory product—jumped from 4.3% to 22%.
- Grievances and Falling Penetration: General insurance grievances leaped 75% over the same timeframe. Concurrently, national life insurance penetration fell from 3.2% in FY22 to 2.7% in FY25 as rising distribution costs made coverage increasingly expensive.
IRDAI's Proposed Reform Measures
The consultation paper "Recalibrating Economics of Insurance Distribution" introduces comprehensive, structural mechanisms to curb leakages:
- All-Inclusive Definition of Commission: Commission is redefined to capture every payout, reward, perk, or foreign trip given to distributors, preventing hidden remuneration from escaping statutory caps.
- Zero or Nominal Commission on Mandatory Products: Third-party motor cover and insurance bundled with loans carry nil or nominal commissions, preventing mandatory public compliance from becoming a cash-cow for middlemen.
- Lower Caps for Open-Architecture Distributors: Independent distributors and aggregators face stricter caps than tied agents, preventing customer choice from turning into an auction for shelf space.
- Ban on Coercive Bundling & Bank Volume Targets: Compulsory insurance bundling with bank loans is strictly prohibited, and volume-linked sales incentives for bank/NBFC employees are banned.
- Individual Seller Tagging & Commission Clawbacks: Every issued policy must be tagged to the specific person who sold it. Incidents of mis-selling will be recorded publicly, and commissions will be subject to claw-back.
- Glide Path for Expense Ceilings: Overall expense ceilings will reduce over a 5-year timeline to 12.5% of premium for life insurers and 20% for general insurers, backed by mandatory cost audits.
Four Key Refinements Recommended by the Authors
While commending IRDAI's regulatory direction, Agrawal and Sahoo argue that four crucial refinements are needed to make the reforms durable and effective:
- 1. Ensure Savings Reach the Policyholder: Capping insurer distribution payouts does not automatically reduce costs for consumers. For instance, a nil commission on motor third-party cover merely widens insurer margins unless tariffs are actively revised downwards. Insurers should be mandated to pass savings directly to consumers through lower premiums and enhanced surrender values, including distinct "Direct Plans" for insurance akin to SEBI's direct mutual funds.
- 2. Reward Policy Persistency, Not Just Upfront Sales: Under the current proposal, higher renewal commissions only begin from the sixth policy year—by which time over half of policies have already lapsed. The authors propose deferring a significant portion of first-year commissions and vesting them conditionally across multi-year persistency, with explicit clawbacks upon early policy surrender.
- 3. Shift Toward Fee-Based Transparency (The NPS Model): Specific regulatory caps become less necessary if commission amounts are transparently itemized in the policy schedule or paid as a separate client fee. The National Pension System (NPS) already functions successfully with disclosed and capped charges, including distinct persistency fees.
- 4. Sequence and Stabilise Regulatory Architecture: The commission framework has swung from caps prior to 2023, to discretion in 2023, and now back to caps. IRDAI must sequence these rules stably in coordination with upcoming public digital infrastructure like Bima Sugam and the Public Insurance Registry.
Comparative Policy Framework
| Regulatory Dimension | 2023 Discretionary Regime | Proposed 2026 IRDAI Recalibration |
|---|---|---|
| Commission Limits | Removed statutory caps; relied on insurer board-approved policies. | Re-institutes statutory caps with an all-inclusive definition covering rewards and trips. |
| Expense Ratios | Rose from 29.6% to 32.1% (General) and 18.9% to 20.2% (Life). | Enforces a 5-year glide path down to 12.5% (Life) and 20% (General). |
| Mandatory Products | Third-party motor commission climbed up to 22%. | Third-party motor and loan-tied covers capped at nil or nominal commission. |
| Bank Distribution (Bancassurance) | Aggressive bundling with credit and volume-linked incentives for bank staff. | Prohibits compulsory loan bundling; bans volume-linked staff incentives. |
| Accountability & Redress | Grievances rose 75%; 75% of Ombudsman appeals found for consumers. | Policies tagged to individual sellers; mis-selling logged publicly; commission clawbacks. |
Read the Full Opinion Column
For the complete unabridged commentary and regulatory analysis by Sumit Agrawal and MS Sahoo, visit the original publication on The Financial Express.
Read Original Article on The Financial Express ↗Original article title: "IRDAI returns to its first duty" • Authors: Sumit Agrawal & MS Sahoo.
Published by The Financial Express (Opinion) on October 13, 2026.
This page contains an independent educational summary and regulatory policy commentary. All trademarks, copyrights, and intellectual property in the original article remain the exclusive property of The Indian Express Group / Financial Express and the contributing authors.